Clinical Superiority Findings
In accordance with section 527(e)(2) of the FD&C Act (21 U.S.C. 360cc(e)(2)), FDA will publish a summary of the clinical superiority findings when a drug is eligible for orphan-drug exclusivity on the basis of a demonstration of clinical superiority. This page will only include the clinical superiority findings for those drugs approved on or after August 18, 2017, the date that the FDA Reauthorization Act of 2017 added section 527(e)(2) to the FD&C Act. “Clinical superiority,” is used here only within the meaning of that term under FDA’s orphan drug regulations at 21 CFR Part 316 and section 527(c) of the FD&C Act. For the definition of “clinically superior,” for the purposes of determining eligibility for orphan-drug exclusivity when the same drug has been previously approved for the same use or indication, see 21 CFR 316.3(b)(3). For the definition of “same drug,” see 21 CFR 316.3(b)(14).
The summary is organized by approval date.
2020
Approval Date | 7/21/2020 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | 212690 |
Sponsor | Jazz Pharmaceuticals Ireland Limited |
Drug | Xywav (calcium, magnesium, potassium, and sodium oxybates) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of narcolepsy |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated for the treatment of cataplexy or excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) in patients 7 years of age and older with narcolepsy |
Exclusivity Protected Indication | Indicated for the treatment of cataplexy or excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) in patients 7 years of age and older with narcolepsy |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
The active moiety, oxybate was previously approved as Xyrem (sodium oxybate) for the treatment of cataplexy or EDS in patients 7 years of age and older with narcolepsy. Xywav (calcium, magnesium, potassium, and sodium oxybates) is clinically superior to Xyrem by means of greater safety because Xywav provides a greatly reduced chronic sodium burden compared to Xyrem. The differences in the sodium content of the two products at the recommended doses will be clinically meaningful in reducing cardiovascular morbidity in a substantial proportion of patients for whom the drug is indicated. |
2019
Approval Date | 01/10/2020 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | NDA 211635 |
Sponsor | Neurelis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. |
Drug | Valtoco (diazepam nasal spray) |
Orphan Designation | Management of acute repetitive seizures |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated for the acute treatment of intermittent, stereotypic episodes of frequent seizure activity (i.e., seizure clusters, acute repetitive seizures) that are distinct from a patient’s usual seizure pattern in patients with epilepsy 6 years of age and older. |
Exclusivity Protected Indication | Indicated for the acute treatment of intermittent, stereotypic episodes of frequent seizure activity (i.e., seizure clusters, acute repetitive seizures) that are distinct from a patient’s usual seizure pattern in patients with epilepsy 6 years of age and older. |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Diazepam was previously approved as a gel that is administered rectally for the same use as Valtoco (i.e., acute repetitive seizures). Valtoco’s intranasal route of administration provides a major contribution to patient care over the rectal route of administration by providing a significantly improved ease of use. Rectal administration is inherently invasive for the patient and difficult to administer, whereas it is inherently more comfortable for the patient to receive the drug intranasally than rectally. In the context of when this drug is to be given, typically in the middle of a seizure event, it is inherently easier to administer the drug to a patient intranasally than rectally. |
2018
Approval Date | 03/15/2018 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | BLA 125350/S-641 |
Sponsor | CSL Behring |
Drug | Hizentra (Immune Globulin Subcutaneous (Human), 20% Liquid) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP) |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated for the treatment of adult patients with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP) as maintenance therapy to prevent relapse of neuromuscular disability and impairment |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Immune Globulin (Human) was previously approved in an intravenous (IGIV) formulation for the same use as Hizentra (Immune Globulin Subcutaneous (Human), 20% Liquid). A substantial portion of CIDP patients receiving IGIV require a central venous access device (CVAD), which is associated with an increased risk of thromboembolic events and access-associated infections. These risks can be serious and/or life-threatening and the risks are long-term because CIDP is a chronic condition. Data demonstrated that patients treated with Hizentra subcutaneously had fewer of these adverse events than patients treated with IGIV via CVADs. Therefore, Hizentra provides greater safety than the previously approved IGIV formulation of immune globulin for CIDP as maintenance therapy for the purposes of orphan-drug exclusivity. |
Approval Date | 05/24/2018 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | 210115 |
Sponsor | Astellas Pharma Global Development, Inc. |
Drug | Prograf (tacrolimus granules for oral suspension) |
Orphan Designation | Prevention of rejection in kidney, liver, or heart transplant in pediatric patients |
Approved Labeled Indication |
The prophylaxis of organ rejection, in patients receiving allogeneic kidney transplant, liver transplants, and heart transplant, in combination with other immunosuppressants. |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Tacrolimus has been previously approved for the same use in capsule and injection dosage forms. Pediatric patients who were unable to swallow capsules received extemporaneously compounded oral liquid tacrolimus preparations, which have not undergone product quality or clinical testing and have been associated with severe risks due to compounding errors. Because tacrolimus granules for oral suspension provides an age appropriate formulation for pediatric patients that avoids the severe risks associated with erroneously compounded tacrolimus, it provides greater safety than tacrolimus capsules for that population, for the purposes of orphan-drug exclusivity. Tacrolimus injection contains castor oil as an inactive ingredient, which exposes patients to the serious risk of anaphylaxis. Because tacrolimus granules for oral suspension does not contain castor oil that exposes patients to the risk of anaphylaxis, it provides greater safety than tacrolimus injection for the purposes of orphan-drug exclusivity. |
Approval Date | 06/29/2018 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | 203255/S-004 |
Sponsor | Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation |
Drug | Signifor LAR (pasireotide) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of Cushing's disease |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Treatment of patients with Cushing’s disease for whom pituitary surgery is not an option or has not been curative. |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Signifor (pasireotide) was previously approved as an immediate release formulation for treatment of patients with Cushing’s disease for whom pituitary surgery is not an option or has not been curative. There are no notable differences in the safety and efficacy profiles between the immediate release and long-acting formulations. The immediate release formulation requires twice daily subcutaneous injections. Signifor (pasireotide) long-acting release (LAR) is dosed once monthly by intramuscular (IM) injection. The dosing regimen of the LAR (once monthly) provides a major contribution to patient care over the dosing regimen of the immediate release (twice daily) due to the greatly reduced injections per month. |
Approval Date | 10/05/2018 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | BLA 761092 |
Sponsor | Leadiant BIosciencess, Inc. |
Drug | Revcovi (elapegademase-lvlr) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of adenosine deaminase deficiency in patients with severe combined immunodeficiency |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated for the treatment of adenosine deaminase severe combined immune deficiency (ADA-SCID) in pediatric and adult patients |
Exclusivity Protected Indication | Indicated for the treatment of adenosine deaminase severe combined immune deficiency (ADA-SCID) in pediatric and adult patients |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
As defined in the orphan drug regulations, Revcovi (elapegademase-lvr) is the same drug as Adagen (pegademase bovine). Adagen was previously approved for the same indication as Revcovi. Compared to Adagen, Revcovi provides more stable adenosine deaminase (ADA) activity that is more consistently above the therapeutic threshold associated with clinical benefit. Also, at equivalent dose, patients converted from Adagen to Revcovi experience higher and more consistent ADA plasma activity. Furthermore, it has been determined that maintaining the plasma ADA activity above the therapeutic threshold is associated with long term survival in patients with ADA-SCID. Therefore, Revcovi is clinically superior to Adagen based on greater effectiveness. |
Approval Date | 12/21/2018 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | BLA 761108 |
Sponsor | Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. |
Drug | Ultomiris (ravulizumab-cwvz) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated for the treatment of adult patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) |
Exclusivity Protected Indication |
Indicated for the treatment of adult patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Under the definition of “same drug” in the orphan drug regulations, Ultomiris (ravulizumab-cwvz) is the same drug as Soliris (eculizumab), which was previously approved for treatment of PNH. The recommended maintenance dosing regimen for Ultomiris is every eight weeks, while the recommended maintenance dosing regimen for Soliris is every two weeks. Because each treatment session of the drug is associated with heavy treatment burdens, and because PNH is a chronic illness, the extended dosing interval of Ultomiris provides a major contribution to patient care over Soliris. |
2017
Approval Date | 09/01/2017 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | BLA 761060 |
Sponsor | Wyeth Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a Pfizer Company |
Drug | Mylotarg (gemtuzumab ozogamicin) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of acute myeloid leukemia |
Approved Labeled Indication |
|
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Mylotarg (gemtuzumab ozogamicin) received accelerated approval in 2000, under NDA 21174, for treatment of patients with CD33 positive acute myeloid leukemia in first relapse who are 60 years of age or older and who are not considered candidates for other cytotoxic chemotherapy. Post-approval studies identified safety concerns including veno-occlusive disease, myelosuppression, infusion-related reactions, and early deaths. As a result, FDA requested that Wyeth voluntarily withdraw approval of Mylotarg from the market and Wyeth complied. The new approval for Mylotarg is for a lower dose and different schedule than the previous approval. In a cross-study analysis of clinical outcomes for patients with relapsed or refractory acute myeloid leukemia treated with single-agent Mylotarg, in comparison to the regimens using the previously approved regimen, patients treated with the new dosing regimen had less early mortality, less hepatotoxicity, less veno-occlusive disease, more rapid platelet recovery and less hemorrhage. Therefore, the sponsor has demonstrated that the newly approved dosing regimen is safer than the previously approved dosing regimen, and thus clinically superior for the purposes of orphan-drug exclusivity. |
Approval Date | 9/28/2017 |
---|---|
NDA/BLA | NDA 208215/S-005 |
Sponsor | Gilead Sciences, Inc. |
Drug | Descovy (emtricitabine and tenofovir alafenamide) |
Orphan Designation | Treatment of HIV-1 infection in pediatric patients under 12 years of age |
Approved Labeled Indication |
Indicated: • in combination with other antiretroviral agents for the treatment of HIV-1 infection in adults and pediatric patients weighing at least 35kg. • in combination with other antiretroviral agents other than protease inhibitors that require a CYP3A inhibitor for the treatment of HIV-1 infection in pediatric patients weighing at least 25 kg and less than 35 kg. |
Exclusivity Protected Indication |
Indicated: • in combination with other antiretroviral agents for the treatment of HIV-1 infection in pediatric patients under 12 years of age weighing at least 35kg. • in combination with other antiretroviral agents other than protease inhibitors that require a CYP3A inhibitor for the treatment of HIV-1 infection in pediatric patients under 12 years of age weighing at least 25kg and less than 35kg. |
Summary of Clinical Superiority Findings |
Descovy (emtricitabine and tenofovir alafenamide) is the same drug as Truvada (emtricitabine and tenofovir disoproxil) under the definition of “same drug” in the orphan drug regulations. Treatment with Descovy in the pediatric population is associated with a significantly lower bone toxicity compared to treatment with Truvada. Therefore, Descovy provides greater safety in a substantial portion of the target population and is clinically superior to Truvada. |